| Platinum | All About Dogs & Cats |
| Gold | Fetch Pet Supplies |
| Gold | Tail Wagon |
| Silver | Winston and Friends |
| Bronze | Pet Supplies Plus |
| Top Pick | All Pet Supplies & Equine Center |
| Top Pick | Frog Family Reptile Shop |
| Top Pick | Pet Wants |
| Top Pick | PetSmart |
| Top Pick | Sassy's Goodies |