| Platinum | TT's Southern Cooking |
| Gold | Black Sheep Burgers & Shakes |
| Silver | Bairs All American Sports Grill |
| Bronze | Lindbergs Tavern |
| Top Pick | 5 Guys |
| Top Pick | Cafe B-29 |
| Top Pick | Joe's Route 66 Diner |
| Top Pick | Taylor's Drive In |
| Top Pick | The Infinite Kitchen |
| Top Pick | WF Cody's |