| Platinum | Hy-Vee |
| Gold | Aldi |
| Silver | Mama Jean's Natural Market |
| Bronze | Old Town European Market |
| Top Pick | Asian World Market |
| Top Pick | Cash Saver Cost Plus Food Store |
| Top Pick | Harter House |
| Top Pick | Price Cutter |
| Top Pick | Springfield Grocer Company |
| Top Pick | Walmart Neighborhood Market |